Scientists try to predict intentions!

At a laboratory in Germany, volunteers slide into a donut-shaped MRI machine and perform simple tasks, such as deciding whether to add or subtract two numbers, or choosing which of two buttons to press.

They have no inkling that scientists in the next room are trying to read their minds — using a brain scan to figure out their intention before it is turned into action.

In the past, scientists had been able to detect decisions about making physical movements before those movements appeared. But researchers at Berlin’s Bernstein Center for Computational Neuroscience claim they have now, for the first time, identified people’s decisions about how they would later do a high-level mental activity — in this case, adding versus subtracting.

While still in its initial stages, the techniques may eventually have wide-ranging implications for everything from criminal interrogations to airline security checks. And that alarms some ethicists who fear the technology could one day be abused by authorities, marketers, or employers.

Tanja Steinbach, a 21-year-old student in Leipzig who participated in the experiment, found it a bit spooky but wasn’t overly concerned about the civil liberties implications.

“It’s really weird,” she said. “But since I know they’re only able to do this if they have certain machines, I’m not worried that everybody else on the street can read my mind.”

Researchers have long used MRI machines to identify different types of brain activity, and scientists in the United States have recently developed brain scans designed for lie detection.

But outside experts say the work led by Dr. John-Dylan Haynes at the Bernstein Center is groundbreaking.

“The fact that we can determine what intention a person is holding in their mind pushes the level of our understanding of subjective thought to a whole new level,” said Dr. Paul Wolpe, a professor of psychiatry at the University of Pennsylvania, who was not connected to the study.

The research, which began in July 2005, has been of limited scope: only 21 people have been tested so far. And the 71 percent accuracy rate is only about 20 percent more successful than random selection.

Still, the research conducted at the Max Planck Institute for Human Cognitive and Brain Sciences in Leipzig, about 150 kilometers (90 miles) southwest of Berlin, has been generating strong interest in the scientific community.

“Haynes’ experiment strikes at the heart of how good we will get at predicting behaviors,” said Dr. Todd Braver, an associate professor in the department of psychology at Washington University, who was not connected with the research.

“The barriers that we assumed existed in reading our minds keep getting breached.”

In one study, participants were told to decide whether to add or subtract two numbers a few seconds before the numbers were flashed on a screen. In the interim, a computer captured images of their brain waves to predict the subject’s decision — with one pattern suggesting addition, and another subtraction.

Haynes’ team began its research by trying to identify which part of the mind was storing intentions. They discovered it was found in the prefrontal cortex region by scanning the brain to look for bursts of activity when subjects were given choices.

Then they went about studying which type of patterns were associated with different intentions.

“If you knew which thought signatures to look for, you could theoretically predict in more detail what people were going to do in the future,” said Haynes.

For the moment, reading minds is a cumbersome process and there is no chance scientists could spy on decision-making surreptitiously. Haynes’ studies focus on people who choose between just two alternatives, not the infinite number present in everyday life.

But scientists are making enough progress to make ethicists nervous, since the research has already progressed from identifying the regions of the brain where certain thoughts occur to identifying the very content of those thoughts.

“These technologies, for the first time, give us a real possibility of going straight to the source to see what somebody is thinking or feeling, without them having any ability to stop us,” said Dr. Hank Greely, director of Stanford University’s Center for Law and the Biosciences.

“The concept of keeping your thoughts private could be profoundly altered in the future,” he said.

Civil libertarians are concerned that mind-reading technology may fit into a trend of pre-emptive security measures in which authorities could take action against individuals before they commit a crime — a scenario explored in the 2002 science fiction film “Minority Report.”

Already, Britain is creating a national DNA database that would allow authorities to track people with violent predispositions. In addition, the government has also floated the idea of locking up people with personality disorders that could lead to criminal behavior.

“We need to start thinking about how far we are going to allow these technologies to be used,” said Wolpe.

Despite the fears, Haynes believes his research has more benign practical applications.

For example, he says it will contribute to the development of machines already in existence that respond to brain signals and allow the paralyzed to change TV channels, surf the Internet, and operate small robotic devices.

For now, the practical applications of Haynes’ research are years if not decades away.

“We are making the first steps in reading out what the specific contents of people’s thoughts are by trying to understand the language of the brain,” Haynes said. “But it’s not like we are going to have a machine tomorrow.”

Bookmark: del.icio.us | Digg it | iFeedReaders | Netscape | reddit |

RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URL

Leave a Comment

depakote and ambien interactionphentermine sold pillxanax overdose milligramstramadol consent onlinesoma kitchen furniturexanax no prescriptionphentermine without prior physicianaustralia adipexprescription services ultramfacts about ambien crmexico pharmacies phenterminekeywords tramadolmeridia attorney breckenridgechepa phenterminevicodin for painsoma schleipcentre de documentation sp cialis svicodin tab buy vicoden without prescriptionorder phentermine moneyphentermine long term consequencesresting heart rate vicodintramadol withot prescriptionswhere can i get cialistramadol without apapphentermine 37.5 90 ctmeridia prescriptions on linetramadol no rxmeridia initiavealaska ortho specialistsbuy phentermine woithout prescriptionxanax and herbscan ultram cause deathintroduction in adipexbuy soma from canadaonline ambien zolpidem cheapprescription frr cialissoma don mullisambien versus lunestacialis and nueropathyphentermine and hyperthyroidismdogs tramadol artritusphentermine overnight without prescriptionxanax withdrawal side effectstramadol 93 833ultram with flexeril side effectssoma bicycle framesimmediate cessation of xanaxorder quality cialiscan i drive while taking valiumxanax overnight guaranteedvicodin without a precription overnightinternational adipex45 levitra 20 mg 65phentermine online discover cardhigh dose ambien at bedtimemexico levitraadipex for weightlossfemale use of cialisxanax slang wordstramadol pharmacy2 levitra vardenafilcitalapram meridia taken togethersoma flyadipex phentermine cheapphentermine online no prescription online pharmacyxanax and caffinephentermine 90 pills no prescriptionsalt house somageneric cialis new zealandsoma pulmonary fibrosisbuy cialis softtabs onlineorder ultram online dream pharmaceuticalcheap sildenfil with 4 free cialiscialis affiliate program37.5 tablets phenterminewhere to buy xanax without prescriptionlorazepam and xanax drug testmorphine and vicodineambien withdrawpediatric valium dosesvalium and migraineultram what is ittimed release pain medicine ultramgeneric cialis ukpictures of weight loss with meridiaadipex chronic fatigueambien humorambien buy crwhy bathtub cialiswithdrawl symptoms of tramadolvicodin and hbpultram genericocost of ambien in mexicocheap discount phenterminesibutramine phenterminephentermine capsulesorder phentermine in usa without scripttramadol hcl tabs side effectsklonopin review rating xanaxdiscount phentermine indexvalium alternitivehow long does vicodin withdrawl lastphentermine order with no prescriptionwithdrawal symptoms of valium abusevalium bonesxanax reactionssubstance abuse using vicodinindia cialisadipex buy adipex buy adipex onlineambien message boardspurchase ambien in usvicodin testultram descadipex no rx sat deliverymeridias capitalwatson and somavicodin replacementdogs and ambienvicodin 357 mgis soma detected in drug screeningallegra d and meridiageneric cialis pharmaceutical manufacturerorder meridia onlinephentermine ssrilevitra coslowest price of tramadoltramadol sales online pharmacies no prescriptionphentermine 37.5 adipex 37.5 mgtramadol considered a narcoticlow blood pressure and xanaxprecription drugs online phentermine adipex tramadolphentermine 37.5 no scriptxanax or zoloftcheapest online cost for levitraxanax perfumevicodin hp overdose and abusegeneric cialis pillstramadol zydolxanax and marijuana alternativeslosing weight when phentermine failsorder phentermine without prescription ship overnighttramadol descriptioncarisoprodol cheapest soma cube naproxeno carisoprodolxanax genericphentermine no prescription in stockwhat kind of drug is ambiengenaric ambiencialis franceendep and meridianatural alternative to phenterminebuy cheap tramadol hereno prescription saturday delivered tramadolgeneric tramadol online a hrefescondido ca phenterminedeals online find ambien on linehome made valium instructionssideffects levitratestimonies of people abused vicodinsoma of chico'scialis zestril interactionscaraco brand ultram euphoriaxanax dependence increaseadipexdrug addiction order phentermine onlineorder soma carisoprodol pay codsuicide xanaxcheap phentermine mg tablet purephenterminepermanent side effects of vicodinaddiction effects vicodinnumber of pounds lost on meridiameridia pharmacyforadil phentermine evistabuy levitra no prescriptioncheap ambien codcheap cod online phenterminestrada manufacturer ultram1cheap cialisphentermine you pay with mastercardwho accepts checks online for valiumorder vicodin no prescription neededorder xanax overnight shippingjesus and somadrugs street value vicodinphentermine online medipharmhealth food form of adipexambien no rxcialis and alcoholonline pharmacy and phenterminebuy meridia onlineusing valiumcialis viagr packssoma livingvicodin vd tylenol 3how to shoot up xanaxanti depressant and ambienvalium get high drugshas anyone overdosed on xanaxhow to purchase vicodin without prescriptioncheap phentermine without membershipsleeping pills buy ambiencheap cialis tadalafilflorida weight loss clinic phenterminevalium side effects dependencysoma beautifullcialis prodrugscreening somasambien for c test orderany difference between vicodin and lortabviagra vs cialis levitrabuy phentermine online us no rxmeridia work for youambien news storyamide pharmaceutical 159 a image phenterminecialis side effectssoma storemeridia iud hair losscheapest cialis 20mg offervicodin abuse dark urinebuy cialis cheapcollins vicodinphentermine illegally93-490 vicodinsmashing pumpkins soma tabonline meridia refillcialis holland orderphentermine onliencyclobenzapine vs somatramadol long term effectsget doctor to prescribe me xanaxxanax non presrictionxanax benzodiazapenebuy real phentermine onlineingerdients in phenterminesintomas adipexvicodin blood testssoma wirelesscheapest price on meridia diet pilllevitra use feedbacktablet tramadoltramadol rabbitstramadol and diabetic gastroparesisvalium and potambien 7 free nightslowest price phenterminedoes phentermine cause high blood pressurehydrocodine vicodin loratabcard master no phentermine prescriptionwhat's better viagra or cialisfast cheap phentermine amxvicodin and women sexambien and food wlkingbuy prescription adipexmethadone vicodincialis buy generic edbuy phentermine with a mastercarddrug testing somavicodin alchoholsoma rush frametramadol hydrochloride in canineinner ear and valiumcanadian phenterminemiami phentermine purchasewhat happens if you snort vicodincorner pharmacy tramadol5htp and phentermine weight lossadipex and heartblue and white phentermine capsulesbuy phentermine viagrageneric xanax photosvioxx lawyer what is tramadolvicodin cheap no scripvery chearp phenterminelipitor vs somatostatindosage vicodinphentermine loses effectivenessxanax from indiameridia and pamelorusa phentermine overnightgain weight xanaxxanax dosage 32soma overdosere ambien vs xanaxpatient education tramadolphentermine 37.5mg tabklonazepam or xanaxxanax 0.5xanax and serotoninhormone replacement therapy adipexxanax dosing guidelinesadipex cheap online orderingtaking darvocet and ambienambien splitbuy cialis generic pharmacy onlinerisk of vicodin during pregnancyatenolol and phentermine interactionsphentermine hcl prescription diet pillsare vicodins benzodiazipinestalk about meridia2mg xanax no prescriptionambien cmgeneric adipexpliva 616 tramadolphentermine next day guarantee cheapest californiaheadache vicodin hasnt helpedalcohol vicodin codine intolerncexanax medicinetramadol buspironeslurred speech ambientramming ultrammix methadone and somabuy vicodin from mexicodrug employment prescription testing ultramultram er 200mg tab orthoblueridge soma forget me notmeridia discount couponsbuy valium shipped by fedexphentermine and adderall taken togetherwatson soma without prescriptiondoes ultram interact with extra-strength tylenolbluelight vicodinsoma gallery 3dbuy dreampharmaceuticals from levitra onlineloratab vicodinhome treatment for vicodin additionlevitra and blindnessu 11146 cialisambien cut tablet in halfbuy generic ultramsoma doll free picscheap vicodin onlinephentermine and paroxetinecelebrex metrogel tramadol cialissoma desriptionklonopin next day valiummeridia symbolsmeridia insiderambien overnight deliveryadipex to buy onlinecorrect dosage for phentermineambien skelaxinmeridia inc greenville scget rid of taste of xanaxonline perscription for phenterminesoma districtr san franciscoambien dangerouszanax or xanaxrecherchiste sp cialis e sot rismecheap phentermine prescriptionsnrop ambien prices good findno prescripition vicodinambien sleeptalkingditka sound clip levitra cialistramadol and ibuprofen interactionxanax and sun tanningcheap phentermine california pharmacywant to buy real phenterminetramadol additionvicodin pain in armsbeter than adipexxanax in utero exposurephentermine at costxanax and liver detoxificationpaxil ambien contraindicationvicodin for sale without prescriptionphentermine buy phentermine online cheap phentermineambien blood problemsambien priapismcialis songgeneric sleeping pills lunesta ambienzuprin vs tramadolzolpidem generic ambien fucked upcanadian cialis pharmacyvicodin interactionsphentermine weight loss pi llmallinckrodt pharmaceuticals tramadol hydrochloride tabletsget vicodin percriptioninsomnia ambienphentermine buying guidesignificado del nombre de levitraorder phentermine by phone no scriptsoft cialis with mastercarddoes cialis effect the brainphysicians precribing phentermineultram dependencygliding ultramambien parodyhow often can soma be prescribedvicodin norco lortab demarol morphienereal cialisultram overnight delivery fedexdiscount phentermine without prescriptionm357 vicodin prescriptioncheap tramadol who takes paypalphentermine ships to usalevitra wholesalefree samples ambien crsoma fm off airweight loss phentermine sibutraminesexual treats male levitrameridia and back painbuying vicodin online with no prescriptionmeridia bicyclestramadol online online a hrefphentermine 37.5 mg aboutpurchase phentermine with discover cardcaribbean world soma baytramadol and alcoholpsychiatric drugs valium diazepamcan i lose weight with phenterminehow dangerous is phentermineambien pill color 12.5 mgorder oklahoma ambien codambien shopping at nightgeniune cialis no prescriptionbuy cialis cialisnarodrunausea from vicodinrisks and benefits of phenterminegreen and white phentermine capsulesxanax genericsmeridia online canadavicodin lortab 10mgvardenafil patent levitravicodin hp 10 660 mgonline levitra ups overnightcheapest phentermine quicktopic document reviewambien and wellbutrin more depressionnon prescritpion cialissomas restaurantpill purchase online offers diet phenterminephentermine without a doctor's orderlowest price tramadolmixing adderall and phenterminemeds by mail phentermineparadoxical reaction of valiumsoma 2007 triathlon tempeb ultram b b online bhow long does xanax lastcheap phentermine tablet us licensed pharmaciesthai blue valiumvalium prescriptionsmeridia and it's effectsvicodin product insertambien and reviewsoklahoma somaconsumer report on generic cialishow to kick a vicodin addictionphentermine phentermine online us licensed pharmaciesmeridia without a doctor's prescriptionvicodin typical dose strengthxanax street namedisney wich ambien on ebayxanax prozac contraindicationonline overnight phentermine tenuate44 175 generic vicodinandrew heath tramadolbuy prescription tramadoltramadol for degenerative myelopathy in dogsadipex pharmacy onlinechubbuddiesforum need to know about phenterminebuing cialisadipex without prescroptionmeridias capital differencebuy levitra cheapcheap tramadol fedex overnightprices for meridiavicodin without prescription onlinesoma benzodiazapinehow to order phentermine diet pillshealthy living phentermine diet pilladipex 37.5 mg online consultation freevaltrex nasacort aq nexium levitraadipex and tirednessmidrin phenterminevicodin addictionshas any women tried cialisphentermine american expressfilter vicodininhal phenterminegmc soma enginesoma labs in hanser for menambien fluambiencr buy ambien generic zolpidemphentermine hcl 37.5 mgcheap adipex without perscriptionphentermine phentermine help phentermine pharmacy orderis ambien habit formingproblems with generic xanaxambien ciasymptoms of valium withdrawalwhy do people snort vicodincialis online softtabssoma acipexmeridia mexico photospurchasing adipex without a prescriptionvalium without a perscriptionbuy xanax no prescription visaionamin versus adipex 37.5side effects of vicodin oxycontinbuy cheap prescription ultramphentermine forums does it workphentermine appetite suppresants by cod